Creative Copyright and AI: The Ongoing Debate in the UK

In recent years, the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) has raised complex questions about the intersection between technology and intellectual property rights. One of the most active areas of debate in the UK concerns the use of creative works: such as music, art, writing, and images, to train generative AI systems, and what that means for copyright protection.

Background

Generative AI systems create new content by analysing existing data and often use large volumes of copyrighted material to operate effectively. As a result, creators and rights holders have raised growing concerns, arguing that AI developers use their work without permission or compensation.

In the UK, this debate intensified when the government initially proposed an exception to copyright law that would allow anyone to conduct text and data mining for any purpose, including commercial uses. This exception would have allowed AI developers to access and use copyrighted works without obtaining a licence. The creative industries strongly opposed the proposal, fearing it would undermine copyright protections and devalue original works.

Government Response and Reversal

In response to the backlash, the UK government announced in early 2023 that it would no longer pursue the broad text and data mining exception. The decision followed widespread criticism from industry groups, MPs, and creators who felt the proposed changes did not strike a fair balance between innovation and the rights of authors.

George Freeman MP, then Minister for Science, Innovation and Technology, publicly acknowledged that the initial policy had been misjudged. He described it as a “misstep” and stated that the government would return to the drawing board to develop a more balanced and consultative approach. He also emphasised the need to support both AI innovation and the UK’s creative economy, which contributes billions.

Continued Concerns

Despite the policy reversal, artists and rights organisations continue to express concerns. Industry groups question the transparency of AI training practices and highlight the absence of enforceable mechanisms to protect creative works from unauthorized use. Some creators have called for lawmakers to introduce stronger legislation that ensures fair licensing arrangements and clear attribution when AI systems use their works.

There have also been calls for MPs and policymakers to take a more active role in defending the rights of creators. Critics have pointed to a perceived lack of urgency in addressing the implications of generative AI on copyright law and suggest that further regulatory clarity is needed.

Where are we currently?

At the time of writing, the UK government has suffered a second defeat in the House of Lords over its Data (Use and Access) Bill, as peers backed an amendment aimed at protecting creative industries from AI scraping copyrighted content. The amendment, championed by Baroness Kidron, would require AI developers to disclose the materials they use and obtain permission from copyright holders before using creative works. Despite ministers’ claims that the amendment could lead to “piecemeal” legislation and pre-empt ongoing consultations, the Lords overwhelmingly supported greater safeguards for artists and creators.

Prominent cultural figures, including Sir Elton John, Paul McCartney, and Kate Bush, have criticised the government’s stance, arguing it enables “theft” by allowing AI firms to use artistic content without compensation. Kidron accused the government of listening to the “sweet whisperings of Silicon Valley” rather than protecting UK creators, branding the current policy “extraordinary” for requiring one industry to hand over its work to a competitor without consent. Labour and crossbench peers echoed her concerns, warning that failing to act now would irreparably harm the UK’s globally respected creative sector.

The government argued that no other country has fully resolved the tension between AI and copyright and that premature legislation could create long-term regulatory chaos.

However, the Lords were unconvinced, with 287 voting in favour of Kidron’s amendment against just 118 opposed: a significant majority of 169. The amendment will now return to the House of Commons for further consideration, reigniting debate over how best to balance innovation in AI with fair treatment for the UK’s creative industries.

Update16th April 2026

The UK government have now confirmed a change in approach in copyright legislation,  which will allow the UK to monitor how other jurisdictions & legislations respond to AI & copyright before implementing any legal changes, following the example of areas such as the US & EU.

This leaves the ongoing debate open, with further conversations expected this year to understand the impact of deepfakes and the problems that may be caused by impending digital replicas.

For now, the debate remains open. The challenge lies in finding a path that encourages technological innovation while also upholding the rights of those whose work forms the foundation of AI’s capabilities.

If you have any queries regarding your creative rights please contact us by calling 0800 069 9090 or  email info@nbrg.co.uk.


Contact

National Business Register

Subscribe for the latest IP news & insights

Protect Your Ideas, Strengthen Your Brand. Subscribe to our newsletter for expert insights on intellectual property, trademarks, patents, registered designs, and business name protection. Get the latest legal updates, industry trends, and essential tips to safeguard your brand and innovations. Click here to review our Privacy Policy.
Free Intellectual Property Good Practice Guide

Sign up below for our free IP Good Practice Guide. By signing up you are opting to receive communications from NBR. You can view our Privacy Policy here.

National Business Register
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.