A recent High Court decision has provided clarity for businesses using everyday language in branding. The case involved easyGroup’s claim against Premier Inn, arguing that the hotel chain’s use of the phrase “Rest easy” infringed several of easyGroup’s registered trade marks. The court disagreed, offering useful guidance on distinctiveness, reputation, and fair competition.
The Background
easyGroup brought proceedings against Premier Inn, claiming that its use of “Rest easy” as a tagline infringed trade marks including “easyHotel”, a stylised “easy” mark, and “Rest Easy Apartments”. Premier Inn had adopted the phrase in early 2021 as part of a rebranding exercise.
easyGroup had acquired the “Rest Easy Apartments” mark from a third party and argued that Premier Inn’s use created confusion and took unfair advantage of its brand.
The Court’s Findings
The High Court dismissed the claim. It found:
- No likelihood of confusion: The phrase “Rest easy” was considered a common idiom with low distinctiveness. The court concluded that consumers were unlikely to believe Premier Inn was linked to easyGroup or its associated businesses.
- No evidence of actual confusion: Despite extensive searches of millions of emails, files, and customer feedback, neither party found any indication that consumers had confused the two brands. The court noted that while actual confusion isn’t required to prove infringement, its absence over nearly four years of parallel use was telling.
- No unfair advantage or detriment: The court found that Premier Inn’s rebrand was a legitimate exercise in fair competition. easyGroup had not shown any change in consumer behaviour or loss of revenue attributable to Premier Inn’s campaign.
- Limitations of survey evidence: easyGroup had relied on survey data to demonstrate reputation and distinctiveness, but the court found it insufficient. Even professionally conducted surveys may fail to establish the necessary consumer associations, especially when the mark includes descriptive elements.
A Wider Pattern: easyGroup’s Aggressive IP Strategy
This case is one of several recent decisions where easyGroup has faced setbacks in its efforts to enforce trade mark rights. The group is known for being fiercely protective of its brand and has built a large portfolio of “easy”-prefixed marks across various sectors. However, recent judgments suggest that the courts are pushing back against attempts to stretch trade mark protection too far. By registering marks that include common phrases or acquiring rights from third parties, easyGroup has sought to broaden its control over brand language. These cases show that while brand enforcement is important, it must be grounded in genuine use and clear consumer association. Otherwise, businesses risk losing credibility and protection.
Understanding the Legal Basis
UK trade mark law protects distinctive signs used in commerce, but it does not grant exclusivity over common words or idioms. To succeed in an infringement claim, a business must show that the use of a similar sign creates confusion, takes unfair advantage of the mark’s reputation, or causes detriment to its distinctive character.
In this case, the court emphasised that trade mark law should not be used to block fair competition or monopolise everyday language. Businesses must be able to differentiate themselves without fear of litigation over generic phrases.
Key Takeaways for Businesses
- Descriptive terms offer limited protection: Trade marks built around common words or idioms may struggle to establish distinctiveness.
- Evidence matters: Claims of confusion or unfair advantage must be backed by solid evidence, not assumptions.
- Survey evidence is risky: It’s costly and may not deliver the clarity needed to support a claim.
- Fair competition is protected: Courts will not support attempts to monopolise language that is widely used and understood.
How NBR Can Help
At National Business Register, we help businesses navigate the complexities of trade mark law with practical, commercially focused advice. Whether you’re registering a new mark or defending your brand against infringement claims, we ensure your strategy is aligned with legal standards and business realities.
If you’re unsure whether your branding could be challenged, or whether your trade mark offers the protection you need, get in touch. You can contact us on 0800 069 9090 or email info@nbrg.co.uk.