Aldi’s copycat brands have been pressing buttons beyond the checkout for a long time now, and it’s not just about the price wars. For years, the discount retailer has been pushing boundaries in Intellectual Property (IP), with a growing list of legal disputes drawing public attention. These aren’t just tiffs over logos or slogans. They reflect something bigger: a shift in how UK courts view brand protection.
Recent rulings suggest that the legal landscape is evolving. It’s no longer enough for copycat brands to simply avoid a registered trade mark, increasingly, the “feel” of a brand is being recognised and protected, even if the imitation stops short of an exact replica.
At National Business Register Group (NBR), we’ve supported thousands of businesses to protect their names, designs, and trade marks. And Aldi’s run-ins with other brands show that brand protection today involves more than just paperwork, it’s about safeguarding consumer trust, emotional connection, and reputation.
From Colin to Copycats: Aldi and IP in the Headlines
From M&S’s Colin the Caterpillar cake to Thatchers Cider and BrewDog, Aldi has been at the centre of several disputes where the core complaint is familiarity, sometimes a little too much of it.
Each case points to Aldi allegedly creating products that look strikingly similar to more established brands, not just in packaging, but also in product names, colour schemes, shapes, and shelf placement. This gives rise to potential confusion and a concept known in law as “passing off” — where one product is presented in a way that misleads consumers into thinking it’s associated with another brand.
Supermarkets have long used this technique to give their own-brand products the appearance of familiarity, without outright copying. Trade marks are designed to help businesses protect their brand identity, particularly names and logos. Registering a trade mark gives the owner the right to stop others from using the same or a confusingly similar name or logo on their own goods or services.
But when it comes to copycat brands, especially in supermarkets, things get more complicated. These retailers often sidestep trade mark issues by giving their own-brand products different names, while using similar design elements: like colours, shapes, or layouts, that remind consumers of well-known brands. This approach allows them to evoke familiarity without directly copying.
The Fine Line Between Inspiration and Infringement
Borrowing ideas from competitors isn’t illegal and in fact, it’s common in business. It’s rare for any product or packaging to be completely unique, and there are only so many ways to signal things like flavour or purpose on a shelf. For example, green often suggests apple or mint, and red is frequently used for strawberry or chilli.
That’s why protecting brand names or logos is usually more straightforward than protecting things like a single colour or a general packaging style. Trade mark law aims to strike a balance: it prevents outright imitation, but also leaves room for fair competition and innovation.
The question is whether supermarkets have taken the marketing too far and so have forced the courts to respond to this.
Recent judgments suggest the courts are taking a broader view, not just looking at whether the names and logos are different, but whether the overall impression left on the customer might cause confusion.
This change is crucial because it elevates how consumers view and connect emotionally with a brand, something traditionally overlooked in legal frameworks dominated by technicalities
Why Emotional IP Matters
At the heart of these legal shifts is a simple but powerful idea: consumers buy more than a product, they buy into a brand. When a business spends time and money building a reputation, a copycat can unfairly benefit from that effort by mimicking the experience.
This is why courts are starting to protect what we might call “emotional IP” : the intangible value a brand holds in the eyes of its customers.
Think of it this way: if your brand is a promise, anything that weakens that promise, or confuses people about it, undermines your business.
So, What Can You Do to Protect Your Brand?
Whether you’re just starting out or have been in business for years, protecting your IP is no longer optional. What is clear is that IP isn’t just legal, it’s strategic. It gives you a competitive edge, deters copycats, and reassures customers that your brand is yours.
Here’s how to stay one step ahead:
1. Register Your Trade Mark Early
Your business name, logo, product names, and even slogans can often be registered as trade marks. Don’t wait for a competitor to use something similar, by then, the damage might already be done.
We can help assess your brand’s eligibility and register it in the most appropriate Nice Classes, ensuring you have the tools to defend it.
2. Consider Business Name Protection
Not every name qualifies for a trade mark, especially if it’s descriptive or used by others in a different context. But that doesn’t mean it’s unprotected. Our Business Name Protection service is ideal for these situations. It helps stop others from trading under a name that’s confusingly similar to yours, within the region and sector you trade even if there’s no registered trade mark in place.
It’s a powerful, UK safeguard against passing off and brand dilution, especially useful for local and service-based businesses.
3. Think Beyond Logos
Aldi’s legal stories prove that visual identity is about more than logos. It’s about how a brand looks, feels, and behaves.
You may want to protect:
- Product shapes or designs
- Packaging layout
- Distinctive colour schemes
- In-store or digital presentation
For these situations, a Registered Design can be your best line of defence. At NBR, we help clients secure Registered Designs to protect the physical and visual elements of their brand — often alongside trade marks.
The Bottom Line: Don’t Wait for Court
Aldi’s copycat brand disputes may grab headlines, but the real lesson is for everyday business owners.
Brand confusion doesn’t just affect the big players. When a competitor piggybacks off your reputation, whether deliberately or unintentionally, it can cost you trust, customers, and revenue. And once the damage is done, legal remedies can be slow, expensive, and uncertain.
Taking action early gives you clarity, confidence, and control.
Understanding that IP includes how your brand feels as much as how it looks helps you protect the deeper value you’ve worked hard to build.
Want Help Protecting Your Brand?
At National Business Register, we don’t just handle paperwork, we help business owners safeguard their identity in a rapidly changing market.
If you’d like to speak to someone about trade marks, registered designs, or Business Name Protection, we’d love to hear from you. You can email info@nbrg.co.uk or call: 0800 069 9090.
We’re here to help, before someone else tries to cash in on what you’ve built.