UK Supreme Court Bars Oatly’s “Post Milk Generation” – What This Means for Your Brand 

The UK Supreme Court has ruled that Oatly cannot use or register the slogan “Post Milk Generation” for food and drink products, this concluded that the phrase unlawfully incorporates the protected dairy term “milk. 

The case, brought by Dairy UK, centred on whether plant-based brands can incorporate protected dairy terms in their marketing.  This marks the end of a multiyear battle.  

What the Court Decided 

The Court found that even within a broader slogan, the word “milk” constitutes a prohibited “designation” under retained EU Regulation, which reserves dairy terms for animal derived products. Because the slogan does not clearly describe a characteristic of the oat based product, such as being milk free, it cannot benefit from any exception.  

This ruling overturns Oatly’s earlier win at the High Court and upholds the later Court of Appeal decision that invalidated the trade mark.  

Why It Matters for Brands 

The verdict confirms that branding and slogans, not just product names, fall within regulatory scope. Marketing teams must treat all public facing language with the same caution as labels and packaging.  

It also reinforces the uneven landscape plant based companies face: while “traditional” terms like coconut milk or peanut butter remain allowed due to historic useage exceptions.  Newer plant-based brands, however, are facing stricter interpretation. Whether this is regulatory consistency or market protectionism will remain debated – but from a business perspective, the risk is now clearer. 

Industry Reaction 

Dairy UK welcomed the ruling as providing clarity on how dairy terms can be used. Oatly, meanwhile, criticised it as anticompetitive and said it creates an “uneven playing field” that benefits Big Dairy.  

The company will continue using “Post Milk Generation” on non food merchandise, such as T-Shirts, where it remains permissible.  

Practical Takeaways for Growing Brands 

If you are building or scaling a brand, this case highlights the importance of: 

  • Auditing all brand language, not just product names 
  • Checking sector or cultural-specific terminology restrictions 
  • Conducting a proper trade mark search before launch 
  • Considering regulatory compliance alongside registrability 
  • Stress-testing slogans before investing in packaging or marketing 

The cost of rebranding after launch can be significantly higher than getting advice at the outset. 

A Word of Warning: Registration Is Not Always the Final Word 

It is also worth remembering that trade mark examiners are generalists. They assess applications across a wide range of industries and may not always be aware of specialist terminology, translations, slang, or “insider” language commonly used within a particular sector. 

As a result, a term may sometimes proceed to registration — only to be challenged later by an industry body, competitor, or party with deeper sector knowledge. 

A registered trade mark can still be opposed or invalidated if it later emerges that the term is descriptive, generic, or prohibited within that field. 

Two well-known examples illustrate this risk: 

  • UGG – In Australia, “ugg” has long been used generically to describe a style of sheepskin boot. While the term was successfully trade marked in the United States by Deckers Outdoor Corporation, Australian courts held that it was generic in Australia and could not be monopolised there. 
  • The Sky trade mark litigation – Although not about slang, the long-running dispute between Sky and SkyKick highlighted how registrations can be attacked years later if filed too broadly or without genuine intention to use. Even large, established portfolios are not immune from post-registration challenge. 

In other sectors, similar issues arise around: 

  • Translations of descriptive words that are obvious to those in the trade but not to the general public 
  • Technical acronyms widely understood in an industry 
  • Code names or shorthand terms used commercially within a niche market 

A trade mark registration is powerful,  but it is not untouchable. 

A Final Thought 

Trade mark protection is not just about owning a name. It’s about ensuring that the name you build your reputation around is legally sustainable. 

At National Business Register Group (NBR) , we help business owners: 

  • Assess distinctiveness and regulatory risk 
  • Choose the correct classes 
  • Register designs and trade marks in the UK and internationally 

If you would like us to review your brand name or slogan before you invest further in it, contact us by email: info@nbrg.co.uk 

Protect the brand you’re building, not just the idea behind it. 

 


Contact

National Business Register

Subscribe for the latest IP news & insights

Protect Your Ideas, Strengthen Your Brand. Subscribe to our newsletter for expert insights on intellectual property, trademarks, patents, registered designs, and business name protection. Get the latest legal updates, industry trends, and essential tips to safeguard your brand and innovations. Click here to review our Privacy Policy.
Free Intellectual Property Good Practice Guide

Sign up below for our free IP Good Practice Guide. By signing up you are opting to receive communications from NBR. You can view our Privacy Policy here.

National Business Register
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.