When the Marketplace Pays: What the Wish Ruling Means for Brand Owners

Online marketplaces have become a growing headache for brand owners. Fakes appear faster than they can be reported, the sellers behind them are often impossible to trace, and the platforms tend to insist they’re simply the middleman. A recent ruling from a German appeal court suggests that defence has its limits, and the reasoning holds lessons for any business that sells, or protects a brand, online.

What happened

The case centres on ghd, the hair straightener brand owned by Jemella Group. In 2019, Jemella discovered that Wish was hosting a large number of listings for “ghd” products that weren’t genuine. It then did everything a brand owner is supposed to do: over the next two years it filed more than 140 reports through Wish’s own IP reporting system, made test purchases and sent warning letters. Yet the fakes kept coming. With its EU trade mark for GHD behind it, Jemella took the matter to court.

At first, Wish came off relatively lightly. The Hamburg District Court saw it as an indirect contributor – a platform that had helped others infringe, rather than an infringer in its own right. Jemella appealed, and in August 2026 the Higher Regional Court of Hamburg took a much tougher line, making Wish directly liable. The court also found that Wish had broken consumer law by failing to tell shoppers who they were actually buying from.

From middleman to infringer

Marketplaces generally present themselves as neutral hosts: the seller lists, the buyer buys, and the platform simply facilitates the transaction. That distinction matters under EU law, because a genuinely passive host is usually only expected to remove listings once it has been told about them.

That protection only holds, however, if the platform really does stay in the background. Since the EU’s top court ruled in Louboutin v Amazon in 2022, the key question has been whether an ordinary shopper would link the platform itself with the branded goods on sale. Thinking the platform is the seller is the obvious example, but the Hamburg judges made clear it isn’t the only one. What counts is the overall impression a shopper is left with.

On Wish, that impression pointed firmly at Wish. The sellers stayed in the shadows, trading under pseudonyms, some little more than random strings of letters and numbers, with no way to contact them. The Wish name, by contrast, was everywhere: on the order confirmation, the payment, the customer service chatbot, the shipping and the returns. Wish also ran platform-wide discounts, could influence the final price, actively promoted branded goods and took a cut of every sale.

In other words, to a customer it looked and felt like buying from Wish, similar to the prior mentioned amazon case. The court concluded that Wish had effectively taken the fake listings on as its own, and so could not rely on the protection given to genuinely passive hosts.

What this means for businesses

For brand owners, it opens up a stronger route against counterfeits. Chasing anonymous sellers one by one is slow and often fruitless, but where a platform is heavily involved in the sale, it may be possible to hold the platform itself liable, if you have a registered trade mark covering the right goods in the right territories.

For businesses that run online stores or marketplaces, the extent of control and involvement matters. Activities such as presenting or promoting listings, processing payments, handling fulfilment and controlling how transactions are presented to customers may all be relevant when assessing whether a platform is playing a passive or more active role, and what responsibility may follow.

Whichever side you’re on, a few practical steps will put you in a stronger position:

For marketplace operators:

  1. Take IP complaints seriously. Have a clear process for rights owners to report suspected infringement and act promptly where complaints are properly substantiated.
  2. Know the sellers using your platform. Appropriate seller-verification and record-keeping processes can help identify repeat infringers and reduce anonymous misuse.
  3. Respond to repeat infringement. Removing one listing may not be enough where the same seller or products repeatedly reappear. Consider appropriate measures against repeat offenders.
  4. Review the platform’s own role. The more actively a marketplace is involved in presenting, promoting, processing or fulfilling sales, the more important it is to understand the potential legal consequences of that involvement.

For brand owners:

  1. Register your trade marks in your key markets. Make sure the registrations cover the goods being counterfeited and the territories where the problem is occurring.
  2. Preserve evidence before reporting a listing. Keep dated screenshots, listing URLs or reference numbers, seller details, product images, prices and any claims that the products are genuine.
  3. Use the platform’s formal IP reporting process. Where available, use dedicated programmes such as Amazon Brand Registry or eBay’s VeRO programme rather than relying solely on general customer support.
  4. Consider a test purchase. Retain the product, packaging, invoice, payment information, order confirmation and delivery details. This can provide valuable evidence about the goods and the parties involved.
  5. Keep a log of repeat infringements. Record what was reported, when it was reported, the platform’s response and whether the same seller or counterfeit goods subsequently reappeared.
  6. Look beyond the individual listing. Check for connected seller accounts, other marketplaces, social media accounts and lookalike websites or domain names using the brand.
  7. Consider customs enforcement. Where counterfeit goods are crossing borders, registered trade mark owners may also have customs measures available to help intercept suspected counterfeit shipments.
  8. Escalate persistent infringement. Where properly evidenced reports do not resolve the problem, take advice on further enforcement options. Depending on the circumstances and applicable law, this may include action against sellers, importers and other parties involved in the supply chain and, in appropriate cases, consideration of the platform’s own role.

How NBR can help

The practical lesson for brand owners is that enforcement starts long before the first counterfeit listing appears. Having the right trade marks registered for the relevant goods and territories, together with good evidence of infringement, can put a business in a much stronger position when using platform takedown procedures or considering further enforcement.

At NBR, we help businesses clear and register trade marks in the UK and internationally and monitor trade mark registers for potentially conflicting applications. We can also help businesses review their trade mark portfolio to identify gaps in protection before those gaps become an enforcement problem.

If you’re concerned about protecting your brand online or internationally, contact the NBR team on 0800 069 9090 or info@nbrg.co.uk


Contact

National Business Register

Subscribe for the latest IP news & insights

Protect Your Ideas, Strengthen Your Brand. Subscribe to our newsletter for expert insights on intellectual property, trademarks, patents, registered designs, and business name protection. Get the latest legal updates, industry trends, and essential tips to safeguard your brand and innovations. Click here to review our Privacy Policy.
Free Intellectual Property Good Practice Guide

Sign up below for our free IP Good Practice Guide. By signing up you are opting to receive communications from NBR. You can view our Privacy Policy here.

National Business Register
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.