The Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC) has recently dismissed claims for trade mark infringement, passing off, and copyright infringement brought by Natasha Courtenay-Smith against Portobello Road traders. The case, Courtenay-Smith v The Notting Hill Shopping Bag Company Ltd [2025] EWHC 1793 (IPEC), is a sharp reminder of how easily businesses can lose valuable intellectual property (IP) rights if proper steps aren’t taken.
What happened?
Back in 2013, Ms Courtenay-Smith’s company registered a figurative UK trade mark for The Notting Hill Shopping Bag. The tote bags became popular, attracting media attention and even being given to the Princess of Wales during a visit to Portobello Road.
However, when Ms Courtenay-Smith’s company was dissolved, the trade mark wasn’t properly transferred out of the company. This meant that ownership of the trade mark effectively passed to the Crown as bona vacantia. Later attempts to renew the mark in a different company’s name were declared invalid, because only the Crown could authorise a renewal once the original company had been dissolved.
When new traders began selling bags under names such as The Notting Hill Shopper Bag and The Camden Town Shopping Bag, Ms Courtenay-Smith and her new company tried to bring legal action. Unfortunately for them, the court ruled they no longer owned the trade mark, had no established goodwill to support a passing-off claim, and their copyright claim also failed.
Why does this matter for business owners?
The outcome was particularly tough for the claimants. The judge openly criticised the defendants’ evidence as “unsatisfactory” and “not credible”, yet the claimants still lost the case. Why? Because the rights had not been properly managed and secured.
This is where the warning lies for all business owners:
- Dissolving a company doesn’t dissolve the importance of its IP – Trade marks, designs, and other IP need to be formally assigned if a company is being wound up. Otherwise, they may simply be lost.
- You must actively renew trade marks – A trade mark renewal must come from the registered proprietor. If you miss the renewal window or don’t own the mark properly, you may lose your rights entirely.
- Goodwill and evidence matter – Passing-off claims rely on being able to prove a reputation and goodwill in the marketplace. If that cannot be demonstrated clearly, the claim is unlikely to succeed.
- Copyright is not a fallback – While copyright protection can apply to logos and designs, if the level of creativity is considered low, the scope of protection is narrow. Competing designs may not infringe.
The lesson? Protect and maintain your rights
This case is a cautionary tale: even if your brand is well-known, even if competitors act questionably, you cannot enforce rights you no longer own.
For business owners, this underlines the importance of:
- Keeping on top of renewal dates.
- Making sure IP rights are properly assigned if you restructure, sell, or dissolve a company.
- Regularly reviewing your IP portfolio to ensure everything is current and in the right name.
At National Business Register, we help businesses avoid exactly this kind of situation. From managing trade mark filings and renewals to protecting unregistered business names through our Business Name Protection service, we ensure your rights are secure and enforceable when you need them most.
If you’d like advice on reviewing your intellectual property or protecting your business name, contact us today by emailing info@nbrg.co.uk or by calling 0800 069 9090.